I test drove the hybrid and eventually bought a PHEV. For me the engines are about the same, although the PHEV seems a little peppier. Both cars don't get great mileage. I haven't been able to charge mine regularly due to a busted charger in front of my apartment, but when I am able to charge and drive all electric, the car is starting to pay for itself. If you can charge regularly and drive less than 20 miles a day total, I think the PHEV will be better overall.
I paid 3k over sticker plus another 1500 in dealer add ons for the PHEV and I think it was completely worth it after the 6500 tax credit and 1658 in state rebates I got. Plus the added benefit of it being considered an EV means you can park in EV designated spots, solo driver HOV lane access where available, and other perks like free parking at meters if your city does that kind of thing.
I paid 3k over sticker plus another 1500 in dealer add ons for the PHEV and I think it was completely worth it after the 6500 tax credit and 1658 in state rebates I got. Plus the added benefit of it being considered an EV means you can park in EV designated spots, solo driver HOV lane access where available, and other perks like free parking at meters if your city does that kind of thing.